Why the UK chose an estimate over telematics for pay-per-mile

Date: Friday November 20, 2026

From April 2028, British EV drivers will pay by the mile, based largely on their own estimate. The Treasury has put privacy and simplicity first. Whether the system works may depend on an opt-in it has promised to detail by the end of this year.

The government confirmed the design of its electric Vehicle Excise Duty (eVED) on 13 July.

Electric cars will pay 3p a mile and plug-in hybrids 1.5p. Each time a car is taxed, its owner will give an odometer reading and estimate their mileage for the year ahead. The estimate is checked against the reading taken at the car’s MOT (Britain’s annual roadworthiness test).

More than 5,000 people and organisations responded to the consultation. In response, the Treasury dropped proposed mileage checks for cars under 3 years old, which have no MOT. It also confirmed it will not require tracking devices or collect data on where or when people drive.

Why an estimate

The choice comes down to 3 things.

The first is privacy. Ministers have ruled out charging by where people drive, so miles driven abroad will be taxed too. The Treasury puts them at about 2% of the total and considers that an acceptable cost of not tracking anyone.

The second is simplicity. eVED reuses the existing Vehicle Excise Duty (VED) payment system and the MOT network, so most drivers will deal with it once a year through channels they already know. Fleets pushed hard for this: the British Vehicle Rental and Leasing Association (BVRLA) had estimated that the original design, with annual mileage checks for new cars, would cost the sector £260 million a year in compliance alone.

The third is the IT at the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA), which collects vehicle tax. The Treasury admits that automatic refunds won’t be available at launch because the DVLA’s legacy systems would need too much work. In practice, it appears that eVED has been built around what the DVLA can deliver by 2028.

What the estimate gives up

As we argued last November, a charge based on odometers and self-reporting is open to fraud and hard to scale. The final design does little to change that.

A new car can now go 3 years before its mileage is independently verified. The Treasury itself accepts that a per-mile charge creates a stronger incentive to tamper with odometers. Its answer is new offences, simple checks at the MOT, and powers for the DVLA to order an inspection when it suspects fraud.

That puts a lot on the MOT network. The Institute of the Motor Industry has warned that the plan assumes every garage can deal with EV mileage anomalies, with no clear plan for how. Much of the enforcement will fall on garage staff reading dashboards.

How others do it

The UK is not the first island in choosing the odometer. Iceland, the closest comparison, extended its kilometre fee to all vehicles in January, using odometer readings that owners log themselves. Drivers who miss the deadline face a fine and a trip to an inspection station.

However, New Zealand is heading the other way. It is moving its 3.5 million light vehicles from petrol tax to electronic road user charges. Its draft regulations would let built-in vehicle telematics act as approved distance recorders, run by competing private providers. For lorries, distance charging through satellite-based on-board units has worked for years in Germany, Belgium and Switzerland.

The door left open

Buried in the Treasury’s response is a more interesting commitment. The government will develop an optional version of eVED that uses the car’s built-in 4G or 5G connection to report mileage automatically. Drivers who opt in are promised a quicker, easier and more flexible system. Details are due by the end of the year.

How it is designed will matter a great deal.

Based on our experience of advising Ministries of Transport in the domain, we see 3 priorities:

  • Collect only the mileage. Connected cars already report it. An opt-in that takes only that figure answers the privacy objection that ruled out tracking.
  • Open it beyond car makers. New Zealand plans to let accredited providers compete. In the UK, that could include fleet managers, leasing companies and telematics providers as well as carmakers.
  • Make opting in worth it. Pay-as-you-drive billing, no annual guesswork and automatic refunds would give drivers a reason to switch.

The third matters most. Our survey of 1,500 US drivers found that most will share their data if the reward is clear, and GM’s $220 million settlement shows the cost of collecting it without proper consent. If enough drivers opt in, the estimate would only be needed for those who don’t.

Our view

The UK has kept telematics as an option for later.

Using an estimate gets eVED running by 2028 on systems that already exist. But a tax based on self-reported numbers and stretched garages will come under growing pressure as EVs go from a minority of the fleet to the majority.

That makes the end-of-year update on the opt-in worth watching. If it is well designed, Britain could end up with one of the most flexible road charging systems in Europe. If not, drivers are likely to be estimating their mileage for years.

Our Tolling Solutions Market Study analyses and predicts how the US and European countries will move to Road Usage Charging (RUC) for light vehicles to compensate for the decrease in fuel tax revenues.

If you’d like to discuss what eVED or RUC means for your business, contact Alex Tallon at [email protected].

This article is under PTOLEMUS copyright.

PTOLEMUS intellectual property. Feel free to use it by quoting PTOLEMUS Consulting Group as the source.